OpeningNight.Online Theater Logo

Who Murdered Love?

A scene from Who Murdered Love? L-R: John David West, Jef Canter, Rori Nogee, Sage Buchalter, William Vraderick, Louisa Bradshaw. Photo by Jonathan Slaff
L-R: John David West, Jef Canter, Rori Nogee, Sage Buchalter, William Vraderick, Louisa Bradshaw. Photo by Jonathan Slaff.
Search by review category

Pianist Richard Dizzoza musically greeted incoming patrons assembling for tonight’s extravaganza with songs from the roaring 20s, and West skillfully accompanied the evening’s stage frolics.

Who Murdered Love was a musical comedy extraordinaire At the Theater for the New City. The scene for fun was set as DaDa Love (Elyp Johnson), and the cast sang Mad for Love. This setting projected a mysterious pallor tempered by the comedic references to DaDaism, which had emerged in the early 20th century in reaction to the Great War. We were set to embrace chaos, satire, parody, collage, and streams of consciousness. We were not disappointed.

The play opened in 1924 in New York City at the office of hard-boiled private detective Sam Speed (John David West) with his frisky, adorable sidekick Gail Friday (Rori Nogee). The cantankerous Speed was recovering from a drinking binge and grumbling about his time during The Great War. Speed was to later quote from Wilfred Owen’s poem Anthem for Doomed Youth.

Moments later, the gorgeous, coquettish Honey Potts (Alisa Ermolaev) arrived to hire Speed to find DaDa Love. Speed tells Friday to send Potts away as witty banter and laughs evolve. Friday cajoled Speed into composing himself, meeting Potts, and getting some work. After all, Speed hadn’t paid Friday in weeks and was beset by his landlord for rent nonpayment. When Speed saw Potts, her talents, and her bankroll, his reticence became a broad smile.

References to Dashiell Hammett’s Sam Spade, the protagonist of Maltese Falcon and Humphrey Bogart fame, immediately evoked chuckles and ahas. Speed couldn’t figure out if Potts was missing her DaDa or sugar DaDa, but it helped to hear her perform My Heart Belongs to DaDa.

So began our playful film noir sojourn into Judy Holliday caricatures, flappers, Freudian slips, and hypnotism. We marveled at absinth-fueled psychedelics, surreal antics, hilarity, charming music, dance numbers, romance, and cleverly crafted Parisian dreamscapes generated by Honey Potts’ DaDaist imagination—the cast exclaimed, “we need to wake her up and get real!” Lighting, music and great songs, costumes, dancing, and blocking were creatively managed with vision, imagination, and aplomb. Surrealism finally conquered DaDa.

Who Murdered Love was a delight from start to finish. You’ll smile, laugh, and revel in the hilarity, music, and action.

The Theater for the New City continues to present engaging, fun, challenging, meaningful, and evocative productions. Their educational outreach programs for children are marvelous and a jewel of New York City. Who Murdered Love runs through February 19. Be sure to check out their site for coming events,

Runtime is 120 minutes plus intermission.


(Alphabetical Order)

Louisa Bradshaw as The Countess Analise

William Broderick as Surrealist artist André Ranton

Sage Buchalter as Ensemble and Dance Captain

Jef Canter as Dadaist artist Darcel Du Camp

Alisa Ermolaev as beautiful, wily heiress Honey Potts

Ejyp Johnson as DaDa Love, the Dadaist artist, and demi-god

Rori Nogee as Gail Friday

Amy Catherine Welch as Blossom, an artist’s model and muse

John David West as Sleepy Sam Speed

Chase Wolfe as young detective Everett Greene.


Book by Lissa Moira and Richard West
Music by Richard West
Lyrics by Lissa Moira
Musical Director Peter Dizzoza.
Choreographer Olivia Palacios
Set design by Mark Marcante
Set decoration, special props, and costume design by Lytza Colon
Lighting design by Alexander Bartenieff
Stage Manager is Lafayette Elizabeth Orsack

Theater for the New City

155 1st Avenue

New York NY  10003

Box office (212) 254-1109

Readers may also enjoy our reviews of A Broadway Valentine’s Day at 54 Below,  Shedding Load, Sandblasted, and Park Avenue Chamber Symphony and Debussy.  

More to explore...

Andre Royo in Audible Theater's production of "Drinking in America," written by Eric Bogosian and directed by Mark Armstrong. Off-Broadway / Minetta Lane Theatre (18 Minetta Lane, NYC). Photo (c) Jeremy Daniel

Drinking in America at the Minetta Lane Theater

Royo delivered a resounding performance, transforming into over 12 characters experiencing the stages of alcoholism and its effects on each character’s interaction with himself and others. At times, it’s hard to tell who Man is, as his toxic masculinity dominates and elevates with the abuse of alcohol.

MasterVoices presents O HOW GOOD at the Central Synagogue. Ted Sperling, conductor. Credit Photo: Joe Carrotta

MasterVoices Presents a Concert of Jewish Sacred Music at Central Synagogue

Tonight’s O How Good was a celebration of the life of MasterVoices board member Lois Conway and the years of philanthropy and insightful leadership characterizing her service. The venue chosen for this event was inspiring and magnificent and set in New York City’s Central Synagogue, a stunning example of Moorish Revival architecture and a testament to the beauty and richness of Jewish tradition and culture.


Who Murdered Love?

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x